Option 1: Do an Israel, get into Pak and POK and destroy all the Terrorist camps.
Option 2: Give Kashmir to whoever wants it and live peacefully. Why get innocent people killed for reasons they dont know.
Ok you can say that then every state will have terrorists and groups provoking terror to cede off. I mean I dont have a solution to that, but I thnk thats quite an exaggerated argument!
3 comments:
hi sujith,
yes i can understand the rage...everyone in mumbai wants action too...and i don't have a great solution but i don't think the ones you're suggesting would work either-
1. attacking pok would only lead to more bloodshed and give rise to more terrorists. don't forget what the hezbollah is doing to israel in return...its not that simple.
2. conceding kashmir is out of the question. tomorrow if they want some other piece of territory do we give up that too? terrorism is a much larger issue and i don't think kashmir lies at the root of the problem...think NY, london, madrid, bali and egypt.
sujith :
1. should've done it long ago
2. agree with deep on this - after we give up kashmir, what next ? pak-occupied-jammu ? give up kashmir and live peacefully ? where, in mumbai ? might as well shoot ourselves in the head while at it ...
deep :
1. Israel pulled out of the gaza strip as part of the peace process, only to have rockets fired from it from the newly vacated territories - atleast it is using its forces when it can ...
2. ' - think NY, London, madrid, bali, egypt ? - good point-
think of terrorism as a virus attack against the body ...
countries are bodies, and each one has its own disease..
i feel this is an analogy that works ..
-trivialmonk
1.NOt at all possible for India.Israels neighbours do not have a full fledged ARMY.Palestinians have a police force only.Israel has a superior defence force compared to any of its neighbours still it is facing so much difficulties to control everything.For India case is not the same and after 98 whole scenario has changed.
2.Not possible.There is no gurantee that Pak will stop interfering with Indi once it has Kashmir.Kashmir is what keeps Pak alive in international forum.
Post a Comment